Flyover Yardage Map Reviews Directions
2469 N Dayton Lakeview Rd
New Carlisle, OH  45344-9578
United States
P: (937) 845-8699
F: (937) 845-3243
Sugar Isle Course

18 hole regulation length course

Public golf course

72 par | 6,754 yards | 107 slope

70.2 rating | Rye grass

Suggest Edit

Sugar Isle Golf Course

The 18-hole "Sugar Isle" course at the Sugar Isle Golf Course facility in New Carlisle, Ohio features 6,754 yards of golf from the longest tees for a par of 72. The course rating is 70.2 and it has a slope rating of 107 on Rye grass. Designed by Jack Kidwell, ASGCA, the Sugar Isle golf course opened in 1974. Bob Smart manages the course as the Owner.


Rate this course:

Reviewed March 13, 2012

played this course on a unusually warm day in March for Ohio...while i have to say the review by softspikes is a bit harsh i must agree, the part about the pace of play was spot on, ABSOLUTELY brutal. i could have played 2 rnds in the amount of time it took the old timers & hacks in front of us took to play 1 rnd!

Reviewed August 27, 2010

here's the real 411 on Suges Isle...this course is *always packed* with local retired geritol townies or leagues no matter what time of day you play. nice folks, don't get me wrong. however, pace can be brutal if you get stuck behind them cuz there always seem to be eleventy-kabillion people playing even on weekdays. best time to play is well, never, cuz the pro-shop can't seem to give an honest answer without a ranger. course itself is your typical country course, wide open layout with a couple holes that can be challenging. quite a few of the greens are absolutely enormous & overall, all of them are *very* slow. over-priced for the amount of courses that are well within driving distance & in better shape (i.e. sprngfield/dayton). club-house is a bust, not really much to it actually. just a counter with a register & 1 hot dog rotater box with 3 JTM franks that were most likely there the day before

Reviewed August 22, 2010

Very nice course,Freindly Pro Shop, Great personalitys . Holes #11,#12, #17, #18. can be Difficult.
Great wide fairways for the Par 5s makes it fun to lay it all out!
Greens are big and Difficult. Make a shot plan

Reviewed July 17, 2006


Very nice course. Well kept, nice fairways and greens.


Add Photo of this Course

Drop Photo here or click to upload


  • Latest Scores
  • Overall
Rank Golfer Name Handicap Gross Net Date
1 David S. 13 84 71 10/17/07
2 Mark M. 9 82 73 07/04/09
3 Dave S. 17 90 73 08/07/09
4 randall W. 23 97 74 08/22/10
5 John M. 33 107 74 10/05/07
See All
Data not available.

Golf Course Information

About Sugar Isle

Sugar Isle Golf Course

Golf Only facility

10 tees driving range

18 regulation holes

Awards at Sugar Isle

No recent major awards have been noted.

Tournaments of Sugar Isle

No local tournaments listed for this course. Add a tournament here.

Course Staff

Bob Smart, Owner
John Soukup, Superintendent